| Year | Result |
| 2090 | Los Angeles (A) Chargers 41, Detroit Lions 20 |
| 2089 | Detroit Lions 26, Baltimore Ravens 16 |
| 2088 | Cincinnati Bengals 28, Texas Tornadoes 20 |
| 2087 | Los Angeles (N) Rams 27, Los Angeles (A) Chargers 20 |
| 2086 | Texas Tornadoes 27, New England Patriots 21 |
| 2085 | Texas Tornadoes 37, Baltimore Ravens 22 |
| 2084 | Kansas City Chiefs 24, Texas Tornadoes 17 |
| 2083 | Baltimore Ravens 30, Tacoma Trolls 27 |
| 2082 | Denver Broncos 27, Tacoma Trolls 9 |
| 2081 | New York (A) Jets 29, Carolina Panthers 20 |
| 2080 | New York (A) Jets 31, Detroit Lions 23 |
| 2079 | New York (A) Jets 41, Detroit Lions 21 |
| 2078 | New York (A) Jets 39, Chicago Bears 23 |
| 2077 | New York (A) Jets 35, Norfolk Navy 31 |
| 2076 | Cleveland Browns 24, Chicago Bears 17 |
| 2075 | Detroit Lions 24, Baltimore Ravens 9 |
| 2074 | Texas Tornadoes 39, Baltimore Ravens 17 |
| 2073 | Cardiff Dragons 37, New England Patriots 24 |
| 2072 | Arizona Cardinals 37, Baltimore Ravens 31 |
| 2071 | Baltimore Ravens 20, Arizona Cardinals 10 |
| 2070 | Cardiff Dragons 40, New England Patriots 28 |
| 2069 | Buffalo Bills 30, Carolina Panthers 16 |
| 2068 | Atlanta Falcons 27, New England Patriots 24 |
| 2067 | Kansas City Chiefs 35, Carolina Panthers 28 |
| 2066 | Cardiff Dragons 18, New York (A) Jets 15 |
| 2065 | Cardiff Dragons 31, Cleveland Browns 3 |
| 2064 | Carolina Panthers 24, Cleveland Browns 20 |
| 2063 | New York (A) Jets 23, Cardiff Dragons 20 |
| 2062 | Texas Tornadoes 36, New York (A) Jets 30 |
| 2061 | New York (A) Jets 24, Texas Tornadoes 23 |
| 2060 | Washington Commanders 34, Los Angeles (A) Chargers 19 |
| 2059 | New York (A) Jets 20, Edmonton Eskimos 17 |
| 2058 | New York (A) Jets 27, Norfolk Navy 24 |
| 2057 | New York (A) Jets 47, Norfolk Navy 32 |
| 2056 | Los Angeles (A) Chargers 20, Cardiff Dragons 6 |
| 2055 | Texas Tornadoes 42, Los Angeles (A) Chargers 30 |
| 2054 | Cleveland Browns 23, Cardiff Dragons 20 |
| 2053 | New York (A) Jets 26, Chicago Bears 10 |
| 2052 | Chicago Bears 31, New York (A) Jets 30 |
| 2051 | Carolina Panthers 27, New York (A) Jets 23 |
| 2050 | New York (A) Jets 17, Detroit Lions 10 |
| 2049 | Los Angeles (N) Rams 45, New York (A) Jets 23 |
| 2048 | New York (A) Jets 34, Los Angeles (N) Rams 17 |
| 2047 | New York (A) Jets 44, Carolina Panthers 22 |
| 2046 | New York (A) Jets 22, New Orleans Saints 6 |
| 2045 | New York (A) Jets 27, Los Angeles (N) Rams 17 |
| 2044 | Washington Commanders 20, New York (A) Jets 14 |
| 2043 | New York (A) Jets 19, Tacoma Trolls 16 |
| 2042 | Atlanta Falcons 17, Denver Broncos 14 |
| 2041 | New York (A) Jets 10, Washington Commanders 6 |
| 2040 | New Orleans Saints 17, New York (A) Jets 9 |
| 2039 | Detroit Lions 20, Jacksonville Jaguars 14 |
| 2038 | New York (A) Jets 23, Texas Tornadoes 20 |
| 2037 | New England Patriots 30, Detroit Lions 10 |
| 2036 | Norfolk Navy 35, New England Patriots 24 |
| 2035 | Indianapolis Colts 24, Tacoma Trolls 22 |
| 2034 | New England Patriots 40, Tacoma Trolls 13 |
| 2033 | Indianapolis Colts 23, Tacoma Trolls 3 |
| 2032 | Minnesota Vikings 20, New York (A) Jets 10 |
| 2031 | Minnesota Vikings 31, New York (A) Jets 6 |
| 2030 | New York (A) Jets 17, Texas Tornadoes 16 |
| 2029 | Atlanta Falcons 23, New England Patriots 20 |
| 2028 | Atlanta Falcons 36, Cleveland Browns 17 |
| 2027 | Atlanta Falcons 27, Pittsburgh Steelers 21 |
| 2026 | New England Patriots 34, Atlanta Falcons 14 |
| 2025 | Pittsburgh Steelers 24, Minnesota Vikings 10 |
| 2024 | Pennsylvania Fighting Amish 28, Denver Broncos 13 |
| 2023 | Chicago Bears 23, Cleveland Browns 14 |
| 2022 | Chicago Bears 16, Cleveland Browns 13 |
| 2021 | Denver Broncos 16, Minnesota Vikings 14 |
| 2020 | Denver Broncos 24, Minnesota Vikings 21 |
| 2019 | New England Patriots 23, Chicago Bears 17 |
| 2018 | New England Patriots 24, Chicago Bears 0 |
| 2017 | Atlanta Falcons 34, Cleveland Browns 14 |
| 2016 | Pittsburgh Steelers 20, Los Angeles (N) Rams 17 |
| 2015 | New Orleans Saints 41, Dublin Galloglass 24 |
| 2014 | New Orleans Saints 34, Cincinnati Bengals 30 |
| 2013 | New Orleans Saints 40, Cincinnati Bengals 10 |
| 2012 | Carolina Panthers 30, Pittsburgh Steelers 28 |
| 2011 | Pittsburgh Steelers 34, Tacoma Trolls 19 |
| 2010 | Jacksonville Jaguars 17, San Francisco Sharks 9 |
| 2009 | Texas Tornadoes 24, Pittsburgh Steelers 16 |
| 2008 | Washington Commanders 21, Cheyenne Warriors 10 |
| 2007 | Minnesota Vikings 20, Pittsburgh Steelers 6 |
| 2006 | Washington Commanders 27, New England Patriots 24 |
| 2005 | Washington Commanders 21, Cleveland Browns 9 |
| 2004 | Detroit Lions 10, Los Angeles (A) Chargers 7 |